Given that the individuals speaking in “Les Invisible” survived by keeping their sexuality secret there is a limited amount of archive film available. Instead their stories are told over modern footage of their current selves in an area of France so achingly beautiful it is hard to believe that anything bad ever happened to anyone.
Their stories are fascinating and there is an argument to be made that each individual or couple would have been better served by a series of one hour documentaries instead of a two hour film which interweaves the stories but the power of the stories still leaves me wanting much more. But that brings to my one major criticism of the film, much as I’d like to tell you more about the couple who met when the godson of one decided his godfather, at the age of seventy, needed a new partner and posted an ad on a dating website or the woman who made the most of her youth but whose sexual confidence went with the menopause I can’t.
Names are not used, instead I can only talk about the woman who ... or the man who ... The participants are of an age where most of us would think they deserved a bit of peace and quiet if that’s what they want but by agreeing to be in this film each has actively chosen to out themselves in a spectacular way but by refusing to use names the film has rendered them invisible again.
The stories in “Lesbiana” obviously benefit from being part of a recent well documented political movement. We can see the original footage and compare it with the reflective current thoughts of the interviewees.
The late 1960s and 1970s saw a burgeoning of political rights movements which included the feminist movement which fed into the nascent lesbian and gay rights movement. It’s interesting to see how, once the lesbian part of the movement gained momentum there was a necessary learning curve of ‘just because we are all lesbian doesn’t mean we are all the same lesbian’. An African American woman will have a very different experience to someone whose cultural background is Jewish or native American or northern European. Some will choose to live in women only settlements, some as part of main street society.
This growing understanding that although everyone in the room shares the same sexuality there are many different identities within the room has continued to inform the movement and goes someway to explaining ongoing arguments within the lesbian world.
It was these women and their male counterparts who brought us equal employment rights, maternity rights and are still fighting for marriage equality but both films make the same point. These right should not be assumed to be permanent. The ongoing recession in the west is giving new voice to conservative voice including those within the UK who oppose equal marriage rights.
“Lesbiana: A Parallel Revolution” and “Les Invisibles” are two incredibly powerful films but they are a call to action not a reason to rest on our laurels.
By Laura
No comments:
Post a Comment